Eight is correct after five plus three, wrong after five times three, and meaningless on a blank page. What am I?

Type:Logic

Need a hint?

One helpful clue
Show hint

Hint: The question decides whether it is right.

Reveal answer

The answer is

An answer without context

Answer guide

Why this answer works

Read the explanation

The value eight is right for one question and wrong for another. Without the question, an answer cannot be judged.

Keep guessing

Related riddles

Random riddle

Ten seconds before midnight I make a room loud; ten seconds before an exam I make it silent. Same numbers, different feeling. What am I?

Type:LogicTime
Reveal answer

The answer is

A countdown

Hints and details

Lawyers build me, logicians test me, and one weak premise can make me collapse. What am I?

Type:Logic
Reveal answer

The answer is

An argument

Hints and details

What is the maximum number of pieces from 3 straight cuts across a round cake, if each cut crosses all previous cuts inside the cake?

Type:Logic
Reveal answer

The answer is

7

Hints and details