I find cracks before publication, improve an argument by pressing its weak points, and work best when the attack is fair. What am I?

Need a hint?

One helpful clue
Show hint

Hint: Researchers rely on it before work is accepted.

Reveal answer

The answer is

Peer review

Answer guide

Why this answer works

Read the explanation

Peer review tests work before publication. Fair reviewers press weak points so errors can be fixed and arguments improved.

Keep guessing

Related riddles

Random riddle

Scientists trust me only after trying to prove me wrong; assume me without testing and I am just a guess. What am I?

Reveal answer

The answer is

A hypothesis

Hints and details

I tell time by copying the sun's refusal to stand still; indoors I am useless, and at noon I almost disappear. What am I?

Type:LogicScienceTime
Reveal answer

The answer is

A sundial's shadow

Hints and details

Ten seconds before midnight I make a room loud; ten seconds before an exam I make it silent. Same numbers, different feeling. What am I?

Type:LogicTime
Reveal answer

The answer is

A countdown

Hints and details